Recently the Township Planning Commission, in its wisdom, decided that one way to prevent medical marijuana “compassion clubs” from popping up like mushrooms in Torch Lake Township would be to eliminate “clubs” from permitted uses in the Zoning Ordinance. This strikes me as akin to prohibiting internet service in order to control spam. I began to think of the kinds of clubs that were thus banished from Township life. Bridge clubs, euchre clubs, book clubs, knitting clubs, model railroad clubs . . .
Fraternal organizations will still be permitted. They have a long and storied history here in the Township, and were fiercely popular among my Civil War veterans. Masons, Maccabees, Gleaners, Foresters, the G.A.R. itself. Others, too, some lost to living memory. Here, for example, is a photo of a “Chamberlain” who might–or might not–be Hattie Chamberlin Arnold’s daddy, Jeremiah Chamberlain. Or Chamberlin. Does anyone have any idea at all of what organization’s regalia he’s wearing? I suppose I must ask Babs, as Jeremiah, if this is he, lived most of his life in Ohio, and they’ll get up to most anything in Ohio.
I digress. Where I was going with this . . . oh yes. I advise anyone wishing to establish a Compassion Club in Torch Lake Township to set it up as the Loyal Sons of Mary Jane and be done with it. You will be disappointed, though. You will most likely not be able to recruit enough members to pay the hall rent on the Sons of Mary Jane building. First of all, very few denizens of the Township will be willing to dress up like that, particularly during hunting season. Second, recreational users of the fearsome weed are fairly evenly divided between people who can afford to set up their own growing operations comfortably at home and people who see no reason to patronize anyone but the local purveyors who have already been in business here for many years. Perhaps I grow cynical in my dotage.
Fierce defender of civil liberties that I am, I determined at once that I must form a club to test the new Ordinance, should it be adopted. What kind, what kind . . . I thought of starting a Gun Club, as that would flummox ideologues of every stripe, friend and foe alike. Imagine the mental gymnastics involved in distinguishing Gun Clubs from Compassion Clubs. Imagine the Cowboy wearing camo. However, I do not wish to collect guns. I already have too much stuff. In fact, one of the main reasons people start clubs, I think, is to have a place to keep all the stuff connected with an absorbing hobby. Hmm.
Every time I track down someone who knows a lot about local history he or she is delighted to tell me all about it and says “No one else is interested in hearing about all this old stuff.” I, of course, am interested. So are the tracked-down fellow addicts. Some of us are planning a little club where we can engage in the despised practice of reflecting upon the past and trying to learn from it. The way things are going, this may be the most subversive activity of all.
Back in the day, one of my favorite t-shirts was a cheery little number with a nice graphic of a sewing basket, needle and thread, thimble–cozy symbols of Womanly Arts. Around the graphic, in perfect Palmer Method handwriting, it said “Ladies Sewing Circle and Terrorist Society.” It was, of course, considered the very height of sophisticated irony. Alas, the t-shirt long ago became cleaning rags. We are in a post-ironic age.

P.j. grath
November 4, 2010
The no-one-is-interested-in-history people need to meet the no-one-reads-books-any-more people. Actually, they might all be the same people. Maybe it’s just wanting to feel special. Don’t we all want to feel special? Your old sewing circle/terrorist tee reminded me of the Sweet Potato Pie novel. Do start a club, Gerry! You know you’ve been wanting to, anyway.
Gerry
November 4, 2010
Hmmm. Lessee . . . the book-reading history-studying sewing circle and euchre club? I think I have identified a problem. It isn’t that no one would want to belong to any club that would have me. It’s that no one except for me would want to belong to any club I devised! OK, maybe Kaye Arnold. She thinks it sounds like fun to get together for excellent treats and a thorough discussion of who lived where when and what they got up to. The why of it is another kettle of fish entirely, and may be beyond us.
Wendi
November 4, 2010
Seriously…that much paranoia in our township that they would ban clubs?????? Am I understanding you correctly? Wow.
Gerry
November 4, 2010
Well, now, there is a distinction between “banning” clubs and simply removing them from the list of permitted uses in the Village zone, which is what happened. Since that’s the only place where they were listed to begin with, they’re gone entirely. In all fairness, I suspect the PC was thinking of “club” as a physical facility open only to members. (I suspect, but cannot know, as “club” was never clearly defined, either in the ordinance or the discussion.) Of course that means a health club would not be a permitted use. Or a country club. Heh heh.
Fee
November 4, 2010
Well, I’m no expert, but that outfit looks vaguely Masonic.
As for a new club name – how ’bout “Sons and daughters of the settlers” which would pretty much be most of the american population, I should think! Or “Fraternal Sisterhood of International Bloggers (and their loyal, nay devoted, commenters)”. Oh, I’m on a roll, here. Or “Brotherhood of Man fan club” – they were a British pop group of the 1970s. Right, I think it’s time for a wee lie down in a darkened room (with “Save your kisses for me” on repeat).
Gerry
November 4, 2010
Jeremiah might very well have been a Mason. I’m eaten with curiosity about the enormous pouch, and the book upon which his left hand rests so formally. (You like the “upon which”? I’m practicing my prepositions.)
How about the Sisterhood of Man? Wait, wait . . .
La Mirada Bob
November 4, 2010
Googled “Ladies Sewing Circle and Terrorist Society” and achieved over 3200 hits. You may even get one of the shirts for Christmas.
Gerry
November 4, 2010
It was a very popular phrase. Save your money, though–if this keeps up I may need bail. 🙂
Karma
November 4, 2010
For some reason, I am reminded today of that bumper sticker that says “Well behaved women seldom make history.” I hope one is affixed to the back of your vehicle, Gerry! 🙂
Gerry
November 4, 2010
Um . . . no bumper stickers at all. I do, however, sometimes wear a message t-shirt even now. I don’t look as good in them as Betty Hoover does, though.
Cindy Lou
November 8, 2010
How ’bout one for Gerry like a pin that I have? “Cleverly disguised as a responsible adult.” 🙂
Gerry
November 9, 2010
I like it!
katherine
November 5, 2010
At first I thought you were practicing for April Fools Day but then realized you were serious. They really did ban clubs? All clubs??okkkaaaayyyy?
Just did a Google search and came up with:
East Jordan Sno Mobilers Club,
Michigan United Conservation Clubs,
Town Club,
Torch Lake Yacht & Country Club,
Sam’s Club,
Rotary.org: Club Locator.
Ummmm, I think they will have a hard time with this one.
Gerry
November 5, 2010
Didn’t ban ’em – just removed ’em from “permitted uses” in the Village zone. That means not so much no club as no clubhouse.
My post was written with tongue firmly planted in cheek. Nonetheless, perusing your list, the practical effect of the change would be to bar consideration of a snowmobilers club or a yacht and country club, assuming those groups wanted to dedicate a building to such a use.
There’s no reason that MUCC or Rotary couldn’t meet in the community room at the Township Hall, just like UTLA.
Sam’s Club would have to content itself with opening its big box store somewhere in the infamous PUD. Good luck with that.
The Clown Tub is sui generis.
kanniduba
November 5, 2010
Ah, Gerry, you rebel you!! 😉
Interestingly, I am rereading the Harry Potter series with Little Girl, and we are in the midst of Book 5, In Which all school clubs are banned to prevent the meetings of one particular group. And naturally, as anyone with a modicum of smarts would guess, this ban did not prevent the targeted group from meeting…in fact, it only made them more determined to do so, and desperate enough to try any measure to avoid getting caught. However it did punish the groups who were innocently gathering, and refused to break the rules to continue. Hmmm…..why do the people “in charge” lack such insight into human behavior as to miss the obvious?
Gerry
November 5, 2010
Well, carrying the argument to its logical conclusion, it would be because they do not read their Harry Potter.
But all of us are blind to how others see the world. The problem isn’t so much that we have these different visions, but that we just don’t listen to each other. That, too, is a fundamental truth about human behavior. Cantankerous bunch, arent’t we!
Anna
November 5, 2010
Civil liberties indeed and I get what you mean. Mayhap, I am thinking and as I see it now, this is a precursor of what is spreading as as police state politics. Loved reading about your t-shirt: “Ladies Sewing Circle and Terrorist Society.” That made me chuckle.
Gerry
November 5, 2010
Oh my! I don’t think Torch Lake Township is trying to position itself as a police state, no indeed. We can’t even seem to keep a Constable. More of a fusspot state I think. Or fusspot Township. No one’s going to pay a bit of attention to it in any case.