Earlier this evening I took the long way home from Charlevoix, winding along the Flat Road. There, across from the Antrim Creek Natural Area, the land rises. Along the ridge, the old tombstones of the Antrim City cemetery look out over Grand Traverse Bay. After a couple of weeks of sunshine and warmth, we are back to March, and a cold wind blew as I parked and got out of the car. I was looking for some puzzle pieces, but what I found was this:
I knew about this tragedy. Months ago I was poring over 19th century Antrim County death certificates when I came upon Price after Price. I looked at the dates and wept. But it did not end with them. In my notes I wrote:
Five tiny Price children died of diphtheria in Banks Township in one terrible week in October, 1879. Two children of David and Mary Bener followed. In Central Lake, three of Mary and Cyrenius Powers’ children died. Their father had died of a fall from a wagon in July. How did Mary survive? In January two Wadsworth children died in Central Lake. Another lived until June, then died.
In 1881, in the fall, smallpox swept through the Indian community in Milton Township. Four Sanoke children, Samuel Nock We Ge Zick, Mary No Pe One Quay – all dead. In 1882 diphtheria struck in the summer. The plagues moved east to Mancelona and Star. Three little Johnstons, two Goosberry children, a third the following spring. Then the two tiny Clark sisters.
The dreadful list goes on and on: Scarlet Fever, Typhoid, Measles, Cholera, Spinal Meningitis, Stillborn, Scalded. Little children died so easily . . . so often.
I did not expect to see the memorial to the Price children, the plea by their grieving parents that we should not forget them. Today, more than 130 years later, we near a historic vote in the Congress of the United States of America. The five little Price children have moved me again, this time to anger.
Congressman Stupak, it is time—past time—to move forward on accessible, affordable health care for every American. Your attempts to stop this effort in its tracks in order to posture and pontificate are unconscionable. There is no excuse. There is no turning back. It is time.
Support health care reform now.
And that is all that I, or the Price children, have to say about that.
La Mirada Bob
March 19, 2010
Yes!
Kathy
March 19, 2010
This is so sad. So very sad… I’m sure the Price children agree. When Stupak reads your blog, he’s bound to agree, too.
Babs Young
March 19, 2010
I urge all of you to read Michael Moore’s open letter to Mr. Stupak at http://www.michaelmoore.com/.
Cate
March 19, 2010
I love going to that cemetery, but some of the stones just break my heart, that one included. It’s so sad – to lose five, all in a week of each other. I wonder if there were any surviving Price children.
Trying not to give into despair over current events…
Gerry
March 19, 2010
Ida, Kitty and Emma, the three oldest Price children, survived. By 1880 Marshall and Sophia had gone to live with her parents in Muskegon. Kitty and Emma were there, too. Ida is not listed; I believe she probably married.
Little Frederick, 3 months old in the 1870 Census, died when he was ten, along with his four younger brothers, who were never even listed in a Census. Marshall and Sophia survived the loss of all five of their sons. I do not know how.
Surely we can manage our times. They are not worse, just different. And the same.
katherine
March 19, 2010
Hear!Hear! As one who has been without insurance in the past and has a multitude of pre-existing conditions. YES, for everyone who has no insurance, pass it NOW. It’s way way past time.
Gerry
March 19, 2010
And even for people who do have insurance, and who are just one claim away from falling off that cliff. As the billing coordinator for the Torch Lake Township EMS I spend a good deal of time each month in the Alice-in-Wonderland rabbit hole of medical insurance reimbursements, and I can tell you that government bureaucracy isn’t a patch on the kind that the insurance industry has crafted.
Anna Surface
March 20, 2010
Oh my, how very sad. Diphtheria, small pox, measles, and even cholera were the plagues back then. I’ve seen the old grave markers and stones like these marking of the passing of the children…
We definitely need affordable health care and medications. My daughter had heart surgery two years ago and the bill was $100,000. For some fortunate reason, as she was uninsured, all but $5000.00 was forgiven… a grant at the university hospital. She’s been paying on the $5000.00 and that is hard for her. However, she is grateful that she got the life saving surgery… she wouldn’t be here now without it. She and so many others like her who cannot afford insurance on their income certainly need insurance for wellness and life saving surgeries. Sigh…… Enough said.
Cindy Lou
March 20, 2010
Add my vote to what all of you said! It’s lng past due.
Sally Ann
March 20, 2010
Thanks for a touching and thought-provoking post, Gerry. It reminded me to contact my own congressman and thank him for supporting the plan!
Paul Blauer
March 20, 2010
Makes me feel lucky to be alive, with a healthy family. My mother lost a year of school (kindergarten) due to scarlet fever, and lived to tell us about it. I will contact my representative to thank him ofr his support. Thank you very much, Gerry.
Fee
March 21, 2010
That memorial brought tears to my eyes. Take if from one who grew up with free (at the point of need) medical care for all – it’s the best thing in the world. No, it’s not perfect, and yes, sometimes tough decisions have to be made (particularly with regard to new, expensive drugs) but on the whole, I’d rather have it than not.
We in the UK take our health service very much for granted – we need to stop and remember just how fortunate we are.
I hope the President’s plans come to fruition – what a wonderful legacy to leave a nation.
Gerry
March 21, 2010
Thank you for adding your perspective, Fee. You’d be amazed at how many Americans think the national health care systems in Britain and Canada are dreadful and unpopular. People will believe any amount of foolishness if it’s surrounded by hysteria.
uphilldowndale
March 21, 2010
I’m with Fee, we watch and wait in hope that the all the people of the USA gain access to health care, regardless of the size of their wallet. xx
Gerry
March 21, 2010
Thank you, Mrs. Uhdd. No matter how today’s vote turns out, we’re in for a long haul. I would say that we might not finish the job in my lifetime, but I’ve been astonished at the number of “not in my lifetime” things I’ve lived to see after all!
isathreadsoflife
March 21, 2010
Such a touching story. How many other families had the same sad fate… I support every word you write, Gerry and hope that all people in your country finally get an affordable medical care. A right for everyone.
isathreadsoflife
March 22, 2010
Congratulations 🙂 You made it ! This is a great day, a historical day.
Gerry
March 22, 2010
Thank you, Isabelle.
Beth Toner
March 22, 2010
Amen.